Bill Nygren: Buy & Hold Beats 35 Major Global Events

Johnny HopkinsBill NygrenLeave a Comment

In his latest Q1 2022 Market Commentary, Bill Nygren lists 35 major global events that could have significantly impacted markets, but only proved that buy and hold is the best strategy for long term results. Here’s an excerpt from the commentary:

Here is an update to the list I used in 2016 of troubling events we’ve been through since we started the Oakmark Fund in 1991. We’ve experienced the following, roughly by year:

  1. Operation Desert Storm
  2. Global Recession
  3. Hillarycare
  4. Fed Increasing Interest Rates
  5. Oklahoma City Bombing
  6. U.S. Government Shutdown
  7. Mad Cow Disease
  8. Asian Flu
  9. Clinton Impeachment
  10. Y2K
  11. Tech Bubble
  12. 9/11
  13. Afghan War
  14. Recession
  15. Iraq War
  16. SARS
  17. Hurricane Katrina
  18. Subprime Mortgage Crisis
  19. Lehman Bros. Bankruptcy
  20. Obamacare
  21. Real Estate Collapse
  22. Global Financial Crisis
  23. Greek Bailout
  24. S&P Downgrading U.S. Debt
  25. Oil Price Collapse
  26. Ebola
  27. Ukraine/Crimea/Russia
  28. Syrian Migrant Crisis
  29. Brexit
  30. Divisive Presidential Election
  31. Trump Impeachment
  32. China Trade War
  33. Covid-19
  34. Inflation Acceleration
  35. Ukraine/Russia

That’s an intimidating list. In 2016, I wrote that despite all that went wrong in the world, an investor who bought the S&P 500 in 1991 and held their position through 2016 would have accumulated more than nine times their initial capital. And that return is despite experiencing eight corrections and three bear markets. (Corrections are defined as a drop of at least 10% in the S&P 500, a level reached in the past quarter; and bear markets are declines of over 20%.)

Though it is tempting to use world events to try to profitably move in and out of the market, it’s hard to improve on that buy-and-hold record by picking the right periods to sit out. Likewise, during those 25 years, the Oakmark Fund had periods of both good and bad returns relative to the S&P 500, but an investor who bought at the beginning in 1991 and held through 2016 ended with more than 19 times their starting capital.

Those 25 years included many frustrating times when fundamental value investing was out of favor, but the 25-year return of over twice the S&P 500 would have been difficult to improve on by trying to guess when our investment style was going to be in favor.

Updating those numbers through the end of March 2022 shows that over the past six years the S&P 500 investor more than doubled their capital, going from nine times to more than 20 times the original value.

That return was despite experiencing four corrections and two bear markets. And even though the Oakmark Fund hasn’t quite kept pace with the S&P 500 since 2016, our investors have grown their capital from 19 times to nearly 40 times the original value, roughly double the return of the S&P 500.

When confronted with global uncertainty, it can be difficult to imagine what the next year or even the next month will bring, and that can be scary. But at Oakmark, we are anchored by an investment philosophy that exploits deviations between current prices and long-term values.

We only own stocks that are selling at unusually large discounts to what we believe those businesses will be worth roughly seven years from now. The events investors worry about might lead to significant reductions in current earnings, but that is usually transitory.

It is rare for such issues to cause meaningful reductions in estimates of long-term business value. That is why in periods of high volatility, as occurred this past quarter, we see opportunity and often make more portfolio changes than usual.

You can read the entire commentary here:

Bill Nygren Market Commentary Q1 2022

For all the latest news and podcasts, join our free newsletter here.

FREE Stock Screener

Don’t forget to check out our FREE Large Cap 1000 – Stock Screener, here at The Acquirer’s Multiple:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.